Some implications of inter-basin water transfers for river ecosystem functioning and water resources management in southern Africa
Keywords:
Southern African Development Community, Water-demand management, Genetic transfers, Invertebrate and fish communitiesAbstract
Inter-basin water transfers (IBTs) are a major form of river basin manipulation. In southern Africa they are increasingly being used to reconcile the problems of water distribution within the region. Despite their high cost and ‘high profile’ in terms of the complex engineering and technical inputs that they require, the ecological and social implications of such schemes have been, and continue to be, inadequately addressed.
Many rivers in southern Africa are shared resources, flowing through or between more than one province or country. The combined effect of climatic stochasticity, rapid population growth and inefficient water infrastructure is increasing the pressure on the river ecosystems of the region. As stresses on rivers continue to increase, re-distribution networks are rapidly assuming the status of a ‘growth industry’, but they have a disturbing and unaddressed potential for intra- and international conflict and for severe ecosystem perturbation.
This paper examines inter-basin water transfer schemes at three levels in terms of spatial and temporal scales in southern Africa. Each scheme augments water supply to the industrial centre of South Africa, the Province of Gauteng. We have selected a temporary intra-basin scheme built for emergency supply within the Vaal River (the major tributary of the Orange River), an inter-provincial scheme involving transfer of water from the Tugela River in KwaZulu/Natal to the Vaal River, and an international transfer scheme centred in Lesotho (the Lesotho Highlands Water Project), which shortly will move water from the headwaters of the Orange River, again to the Vaal River. These schemes illustrate some of the extremely complex ecological, geomorphological, chemical, social and political ramifications that occur when river basins are manipulated for water supply. Although pleas for detailed ecological studies of the effects of IBTs have been made over the past decade, they have fallen on deaf ears in administrative, engineering and political circles. We again caution that IBTs can be highly problematic, and expand the plea for intelligent and integrated planning and management, and for strict adherence to Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Integrated Environmental Management (IEM) procedures for both future and extant schemes in the region.
References
Alexander, W.J.R. 1985. “Hydrology of low-latitude Southern Hemisphere land masses”. In Perspectives in Southern Hemisphere Limnology. Developments in Hydrobiology, Edited by: Davies, B.R. and Walmsley, R.D. Vol. 28, 75–83. Dordrecht: Dr. W. Junk. In
Bailey, R.G. and Cobb, S.M. 1984. A note on some investigations carried out in the area of the Sudan Plain to be affected by the Jonglei Canal. Hydrobiologia, 110: 45–46.
Beadle, L.C. 1981. The Inland Waters of Tropical Africa: an introduction to tropical limnology, 2nd Edition, New York and London: Longman.
Benade, C. 1993. “Management proposals for the regulated Orange River system within the borders of the Cape Province”. In Report prepared for the Northern Cape Scientific Services branch of the Cape Nature Conservation and Museums, Kimberley
Bethune, S. and Chivell, E. 1985. Environmental aspects of the Eastern National Water Carrier. South West African Annual, : 23–27.
Bethune, S., Puz, A. and Roeis, R. 1984. “Changes to water quality due to long distance transport”. In Internal Report to the Department of Water Affairs, South West Africa/Namibia, Division of Research and Special Investigation, Windhoek
Britton, D.L. 1990a. A study of a Cape Mountain Stream Ecosystem and its Response to fire, Freshwater Research Unit, University of Cape Town. Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis
Britton, D.L. 1990. Fire and the dynamics of allochthonous detritus in a South African mountain stream. Freshwat. Biol., 24: 347–360.
Cambray, J.A. and Jubb, R.A. 1977. Dispersal of Fishes via the Orange-Fish Tunnel, South Africa. J. Limnol. Soc. Sth. Afr., 3(1): 33–35.
Cambray, J.A. and Jubb, R.A. 1977. The Orange-Fish tunnel. Piscator, 99: 4–6.
Car, M. 1983. The influence of water-level fluctuation on the drift of Simulium chutteri Lewis, 1965 (Diptera, Nematocera) in the Orange River, South Africa. Onderst. J. of Vet. Res., 50: 173–177.
Car, M. and de Moor, F.C. 1984. The response of the Vaal River drift and benthos to Simulium (Diptera: Nematocera) control using Bacillus thuringiensis var. israelensis (H-14). Onderst. J. of Vet. Res., 51: 155–160.
Chang Ming, L., Dakang, Z. and Yuexian, X. 1985. “Water transfer in China: the East Route Project”. In Large-scale Water Transfers: Emerging Environmental and Social Experiences, United Nations Environmental Programmes, Water Resources Series Edited by: Golubev, G.N. and Biswas, A.K. Vol. 7, 103–118. Oxford: Tycooly Publishing. In
Charnock, A. 1983. A new course for the Nile. New Sci., 27: 281–288.
Chutter, F.M. 1993a. “Lesotho Highlands Water Project”. In Contract 83 — Baseline water quality and aquatic communities study — Phase 1A. Draft Final Report to the Lesotho Highlands Development Authority
Chutter, F.M. 1993b. Lesotho Highlands Project: Impact on Aquatic Ecosystems. Proceedings of the 1993 Water Institute of South Africa (WISA) Conference, 1: 142–153.
Chutter, F.M. and Ashton, P.J. 1990. A preliminary report on the impact of Lesotho Highlands Water on the As/Liebenbergsvlei/Wilge River ecosystem, Report no. V/D110/00/E001 Pretoria, , South Africa: Department of Water Affairs and Forestry.
Chutter, F.M., Ashton, P.J. and Hely-Hutchinson, J.R. 1988. “Predicted limnological conditions in Phase 1A of the Lesotho Highlands Development Scheme”. In Report to the Lesotho Highlands Development Authority, Maseru, Lesotho
Chutter, F.M. and Heath, R.G.M. 1992. A further relevant environmental impact study of the flow of water transferred from the LHWP to South Africa on ecosystems of the Ash, Liebenbergsvlei, Wilge and Little Caledon Rivers, Report no. V/D110/00/E002 Pretoria, , South Africa: Department of Water Affairs and Forestry.
Clayton, A.J. 1994. Annual Report of the City Engineer, 1993/1994, South Africa: Cape Town City Council.
Comrie-Greig, J. 1986. The ENWC, ‘killer Canal’ or life-giving artery, or both?. African Wildlife, 40: 68–73.
Conley, A.H. 1995. “A synoptic view of water resources in Southern Africa”. In Paper to South African Department of Water Affairs and Forestry Pretoria
Craig, J.F. and Kemper, J.B., eds. 1987. Regulated Streams: Advances in Ecology, New York and London: Plenum Press.
Critchfield, R. 1978. Crocodiles, cattle and the Jonglei Canal. International Wildlife, 8: 20–25.
Davies, B.R. and Day, J.A. 1986. The Biology and Conservation of South Africa's Vanishing Waters, Cape Town: Department of Extra-Mural Studies, University of Cape Town and the Wildlife Society of Southern Africa, Western Cape Branch.
Davies, B.R. and Day, J.A. 1998. Vanishing Waters, Cape Town: University of Cape Town Press.
Davies, B.R., O'Keeffe, J.H. and Snaddon, C.D. 1993a. A Synthesis of the Ecological Functioning, Conservation and Management of South African River Ecosystems, Report No. WRC TT62/93 Pretoria, , South Africa: Water Research Commission.
Davies, B.R., O'Keeffe, J.H. and Snaddon, C.D. 1995. “River and stream ecosystems in southern Africa: predictably unpredictable”. In Rivers and Stream Ecosystems, Edited by: Cushing, C.E., Cummins, K.W. and Minshall, G.W. 537–599. New York: Elsevier. In
Davies, B.R., Thoms, M. and Meador, M. 1992. The ecological impacts of inter-basin water transfers: and their threats to river basin integrity and conservation. Aquat. Conserv.: Mar. and Freshw. Ecosyst, 2: 325–349.
Davies, B.R., Thoms, M., Walker, K.F., O'Keeffe, J.H. and Gore, J.A. 1993b. “Dryland Rivers: Their ecology, conservation and management”. In The Rivers Handbook, Edited by: Calow, P. and Petts, G.E. Vol. 2, Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications. In
Davies, B.R. and Walker, K.F. 1986. “River systems as ecological units: an introduction to the ecology of river systems”. In The Ecology of River Systems, Monogr. Biol. Edited by: Davies, B.R. and Walker, K.F. Vol. 60, 1–8. In
de Moor, F.C. 1982. A community of Simulium species in the Vaal River near Warrenton, Johannesburg: University of the Witwatersrand. Unpublished PhD Thesis
de Moor, F.C. 1986. “Invertebrates of the Lower Vaal River, with emphasis on the Simuliidae”. In The Ecology of River Systems, Monogr. Biol. Edited by: Davies, B.R. and Walker, K.F. Vol. 60, 135–142. Dordrecht: Dr W. Junk. In
DWA. 1987. “Tugela-Vaal Scheme”. In Pamphlet compiled and issued by the Liaison Division of the Dept of Water Affairs
DWAF. 1985. The Lesotho Highlands Scheme: A Water Supply, ‘Super Project’. South African Construction World (Johannesburg), Supplement to the Dambuilders: 75 years with the Department of Water Affairs
DWAF. 1986. Management of the Water Resources of the Republic of South Africa, Pretoria: Department of Water Affairs.
DWAF. 1991a. Water supply to the Eastern Transvaal Highveld, Pretoria: Pumphlet compiled and issued by Liaison Services, Department of Water Affairs.
DWAF. 1991b. Waterdata, Pretoria: Department of Water Affairs. Pamphlet issued by Liaison Services
DWAF. 1994. Water Supply and Sanitation Policy, Government White Paper on Water — an Indivisible National Asset Pretoria: Department of Water Affairs.
Gavaghan, H. 1986. A Saline Solution to Israel's Drought. New Sci., : 26–27.
Golubev, G.N. and Biswas, A.K. 1979. Interregional Water Transfers, Problems and Prospects, Oxford and New York: Pergamon Press.
Golubev, G.N. and Biswas, A.K. 1985. “Large-scale water transfers: emerging environmental and social issues”. In Large-Scale Water Transfers: Emerging Environmental and Social Experiences, United Nations Environmental Programmes, Water Resources Series Edited by: Golubev, G.N. and Biswas, A.K. Vol. 7, 103–118. Oxford: Tycooly Publishing. In
Gore, J.A. and Petts, G.E., eds. 1989. Alternatives in Regulated River Management, Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press Inc..
Gourou, P. 1970. L'Afrique, Paris: Hachette.
Heritage, G. Receiving Rivers Geomorphology: Channel Stability Evaluation and Ameliorative Measures. Impact Management Workshop Background Information Document Prepared for Umgeni Water by Steffen, Robertson and Kirsten Consulting Engineers. October 1995, Johannesburg, South Africa. Mooi-Umgeni Transfer Scheme Receiving Rivers Impact Management Study, In
Heyns, P., Masundire, H. and Sekwale, M. 1994. “Freshwater resources”. In State of Southern African Research and Documentation Centre, International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Southern African Development Community, Edited by: Chenje, M. and Johnson, P. Johannesburg: Penrose Press. In
Hughes, J.M., Bunn, S.E., Kingston, D.M. and Hurwood, D.A. 1995. Genetic differentiation and dispersal among populations of Paratya australiensis (Atyidae) in rainforest streams in southeast Queensland, Australia. J. N. Am. Benth. Soc., 14: 158–173.
Hughes, J.M., Bunn, S.E., Hurwood, D.A., Choy, S. and Pearson, R.G. 1996. Genetic differentiation among populations of Caridina zebra (Decapoda, Atyidae) in tropical rainforest streams, northern Australia. Freshwat. Biol., 36: 289–296.
Jacobson, P.J., Jacobson, K.M. and Seely, M.K. 1995. Ephemeral Rivers and their catchments: Sustaining People and Development in Western Namibia, Windhoek: Desert Research Foundation of Namibia.
Kapuscinski, A.R. and Hallerman, E.M. 1991. Implications of introduction of transgenic fish into natural ecosystems. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 48(suppl. 1): 99–107.
King, J.M., Day, J.A., Davies, B.R. and Henshall-Howard, M.-P. 1987. Particulate organic matter in a mountain stream in the south-western Cape, South Africa. Hydrobiol., 154: 165–187.
King, J.M., Henshall-Howard, M.P., Day, J.A. and Davies, B.R. 1987. Leaf-pack dynamics in a Southern African mountain stream. Freshwat. Biol., 18: 325–340.
King, J.M., Day, J.A., Hurley, P.R., Henshall-Howard, M.-P. and Davies, B.R. 1988. Macroinvertebrate communities and environment in a Southern African mountain stream. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 45: 2168–2181.
Leach, J.H. and Lewis, C.A. 1991. Fish introductions in Canada: provincial views and regulations. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 48(Suppl. 1): 156–161.
/4. Lesotho Highlands Development Authority Annual Report, Maseru: Lesotho Highlands Development Authority.
Lesotho Highlands Water Project 1992 WATERTEK obtains contract for water study, Vol. 6, 1–1. South Africa: WATERTEK Newsletter, CSIR.
Lillehammer, A. and Saltviet, S.J., eds. 1984. Regulated Rivers, Oslo: Universitesforlaget AS.
Martin, L. 1993. Sharing international waters to sustain life. Namibian Review, 1993: 1–8.
McMahon, T.A. and Mein, R.G. 1986. River and Reservoir Yield, Colorado: Water Resources Publications.
Meador, M. 1992. Inter-basin water transfers. Ecological concerns. Fisheries (Bethesda), 17: 17–22.
Micklin, P.P. 1986. The status of the Soviet Union's North-South Water Transfer Projects Before their Abandonment in 1985–86. Soviet Geogr. — Rev. and Transln, 27(5): 287–329.
Overman, M. 1976. Water: Solutions to a Problem of Supply and Demand Revised ed, Oxford Univ. Press.
Palmer Development Group. 1995. Review of rural sanitation in South Africa: the Mvula Trust, South African Water Research Commission Report No. KV 71/95
Petitjean, M.O.G. and Davies, B.R. 1988 a. Ecological and Environmental Impacts of Inter-basin Water Transfer Schemes in Southern Africa — A Review, Pretoria: Foundation for Research and Development, CSIR.
Petitjean, M.G.O. and Davies, B.R. 1988. Ecological impacts of inter-basin water transfers: Some case studies, research requirements and assessment procedure in Southern Africa. S. Afr. J. of Sci., 84: 819–828.
Petts, G.E. 1984. Impounded Rivers, John Wiley and Sons.
Petts, G.E., Armitage, P. and Gustard, A., eds. 1989. Fourth International Symposium on Regulated Streams, Reg. Riv.: Res. and Mngmnt Vol. 3, 392–392.
Pitchford, R. 1953. Some Observations on Aquatic Snails in Relation to Centrifugal and Hydraulic Van Pumps. Publ. Hlth (Johannesburg), 17: 325–327.
Pitman, W.V. and Hudson, J. 1994. “A broad overview of present and potential water resource linkages in southern Africa”. In Report prepared by Stewart Scott Inc. Johannesburg, for the Development Bank of Southern Africa
Preston, G.R., Robins, N. and Fuggle, R.F. 1992. “Integrated Environmental Management”. In Environmental Management in South Africa, Edited by: Fuggle, R.F. and Rabie, M.A. Cape Town: Juta and Co. Ltd. Chapter 30 In
Pretorius, S.J., Oberholzer, G. and Van Eeden, J.A. 1976. Die Tugela-Vaal Staatswaterskema as 'n Bilharzia risiko. S. Afr. Med. J., 50: 968–982.
Roberts, C.P.R. and Erasmus, J.J. 1982. Environmental Considerations of the Drakensberg Pumped Storage Scheme. Civ. Engnr S. Afr., 24(8): 361–373.
Senqu River Instream Flow Requirements Workshop. 1995. Senqu River Instream Flow Requirements Workshop Final Report.
Simons, D.B. 1979. “Effects of stream regulation on channel morphology”. In The Ecology of Regulated Streams, Edited by: Ward, J.V. and Stanford, J.A. New York: Plenum Press. In
Snaddon, C.D. and Davies, B.R. 1998. A preliminary assessment of the effects of a small inter-basin water transfer, the Riviersonderend-Berg River Transfer Scheme, Western Cape, South Africa, on discharge and invertebrate community structure. Submitted to Reg. Riv.: Res. and Mngmnt, 14: 421–441.
Stanley Consultants. 1995. SARP — Southern Africa Regional Water Sector Assessment, Final Report to United States Agency for International Development Vol. 1,
Thomas, D.S.G. 1989. “The nature of arid environments”. In Arid Zone Geomorphology, Edited by: Thomas, D.S.G. New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.. In
Thomas, G.W. and Box, T.W. 1969. “Social and ecological implications of water importation into arid lands”. In Arid Lands in Perspective, Edited by: Bagley, J.M. and Smiley, T.L. Tucson: University of Arizona Press. In
van Niekerk, P.H., van Rooyen, J.A., Stoffberg, F.A. and Basson, M.S. Water for South Africa into the 21st Century. Paper presented at the IAHR Bi-Ennial Congress. August 5–7, Sun City, South Africa.
Voropaev, G.V. and Velikanov, A.L. 1985. “Partial southward diversions of northern and Siberian rivers”. In Large-scale Water Transfers: Emerging Environmental and Social Experiences, United Nations Environmental Programmes, Water Resources Series Vol. 7, Edited by: Golubev, G.N. and Biswas, A.K. 103–118. Oxford: Tycooly Publishing. In
Ward, J.V. and Stanford, J.A., eds. 1979. The Ecology of Regulated Streams, New York and London: Plenum Press.
Ward, J.V. and Stanford, J.A. 1983 a. “The Serial Discontinuity Concept of lotic ecosystems”. In Dynamics of lotic ecosystems, Edited by: Fontaine, T.D. and Bartell, S.M. Michigan: Ann Arbor Science Publishers. In
Ward, J.V. and Stanford, J.A. 1983b. “The intermediate disturbance hypothesis: An explanation for biotic diversity patterns in lotic ecosystems”. In Dynamics of Lotic Ecosystems, Edited by: Fontaine, T.D. and Bartell, S.M. 347–356. Michigan: Ann Arbor Science Publishers. In
Wingate, P.J. 1991. U.S. State's view on regulations on fish introductions. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 48(Suppl. 1): 167–170.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Manuscripts must be original. They must not be published or be under consideration for publication elsewhere, in whole or in part. It is required that the lead author of accepted papers complete and sign the MSU Press AEHM Author Publishing Agreement and provide it to the publisher upon acceptance.
