Integrating mesocosm experiments with field and laboratory studies to generate Weight-of-Evidence risk assessments for ecosystem health
Keywords:
cumulative effects, benthic invertebrates, periphyton, pulp millAbstract
Assessing ecosystem health of large rivers is often complicated because these ecosystems receive multiple, interacting effluent discharges. Confounding factors, such as complicated mixing hydraulics and historical loading effects, can result in equivocal field data that lend weak inference to ecological risk assessments. Within Environment Canada's National Water Research Institute (NWRI) one approach to this problem develops a strategy that defines important mechanisms of pollutant effects through the combined use of laboratory and field measurements, riverside mesocosm experiments, and the incorporation of indicators at several trophic levels. We integrate these different types of information through weight-of-evidence postulates that provide logical guidelines for establishing causation in ecological risk assessment. Using this approach, retrospective risk assessments on a number of Canadian rivers indicates that the major effect of present effluent discharges from pulp mills has been one of nutrient enrichment and stimulation of food web productivity. The combination of field experiments with this weight-of-evidence approach yielded the scientific justification for a conceptual model that describes community shifts across a nutrient-contaminant gradient. The purpose of this is paper is to illustrate the utility of riverside mesocosms in assessing ecological impacts of point-source discharges. We conclude that the use of stream mesocosms with the weight-of-evidence approach is highly useful for establishing a mechanistic understanding of community responses to stressors at a regional scale. In addition, this approach will be useful when greater understanding of a particular class of anthropogenic stressors (e.g., specific types of effluent) is required to improve regulatory guidelines.
References
Bothwell, M. L. 1993. “Artificial streams in the study of algal/nutrient dynamics.”. In Research in Artificial Streams: Applications. Uses and Abuses, Edited by: Lamberti, G. A. and Steinman, A. D. Vol. 12, 237–333. 313–384. J. N. Am Benthol. Soc..
Cash, K. J. and Gulp, J. M. 1996. “The effects of bleached kraft pulp mill effluent on periphyton tissue”. In Fraser River Action Plan, Environmental Conservation Branch, 37Vancouver, B.C.: Environment Canada. DOE FRAP 1996-08
Cash, K. J., Ouellette, M. S. J., Wrona, F. J. and Wagner, G. 1996. An assessment of the utility of benthic macroinvertebrate and fish community structure in biomonitoring of the Peace, Athabasca, and Slave river basins, Report No. 123 Edmonton, AB, , Canada: Northern River Basins Study..
Culp, J. M. and Cash, K. J. 1995. Potential impacts of effluent on the Thompson and upper Fraser Rivers, DOE FRAP1995-10 Vancouver, BC, , Canada: Fraser River Action Plan, Environmental Conservation Branch, Environment Canada.
Culp, J. M. and Lowell, R. B. 1998. “Pulp mill effluent impacts on benthic communities and selected fish species in the Fraser River Basin.”. In Health of the Fraser River Aquatic Ecosystem, DOE FRAP 1998-11 Edited by: Gray, C. and Tuominen, T. Vol. II, 13–34. Ottawa, ON, , Canada: Environment Canada.
Culp, J. M. and Podemski, C. L. 1996. “Design and application of a novel stream microcosm system for assessing effluent impacts to large rivers.”. In Environmental Fate and Effects of Pulp and Paper Mill Effluents, Edited by: Servos, M. R., Munkittrick, K. R., Carey, J. H. and Van Der Kraak, G. J. 549–555. Delray Beach, FL, , USA: St. Lucie Press.
Culp, J. M., Podemski, C. L., Cash, K. J. and Lowell, R. B. 1996. Utility of field-based artificial streams for assessing effluent effects on riverine ecosystems. J. Aquat. Ecosyst. Health, 5: 117–124.
Culp, J. M., Lowell, R. B. and Cash, K. J. 2000a. Integrating mesocosm experiments with field and laboratory studies to generate weight-of-evidence risk assessments for large rivers. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 19: 1167–1173.
Culp, J. M., Podemski, C. L., Cash, K. J. and Lowell, R. B. 2000b. A research strategy for using stream microcosms in ecotoxicology: integrating experiments at different levels of biological organization with field data. J. Aquat. Ecosyst. Stress and Recov., 7: 167–176.
Culp, J. M., Podemski, C. L. and Cash, K. J. 2000c. Interactive effects of nutrients and contaminates from pulp mill effluents on riverine benthos. J. Aquat. Ecosyst. Stress and Recov., 8: 67–75.
Dubé, M. G. and CuIp, J. M. 1996. Growth responses of periphyton and chironomids exposed to biologically treated bleached kraft pulp mill effluent. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 15: 2019–2027.
Dube, M. G. and MacLatchy, D. L. 2000a. Endocrine responses of an estuarine fish Fundulus heteroclites to final effluent from a bleached kraft pulp mill before and after installation of reverse osmosis treatment of a waste stream. Environ. Toxicol. Chem, 19: 2788–2796.
Dube, M. G. and MacLatchy, D. L. Reverse osmosis treatment of condensates from a bleached kraft pulp mill: effects on acute and chronic toxicity of process streams and final effluent. Proceedings, 4th International Conference on Environmental Impacts of the Pulp and Paper Industry. Helsinki, Finland. Edited by: Ruoppa, M., Paasivirta, J., Lehtinen, K.-J. and Ruonala, S. pp.270–276.
Dube, M. G. and MacLatchy, D. L. 2001. Identification and treatment of a waste stream at a bleached kraft pulp mill that depresses a sex steroid in the mummichog (Fundulus heteroclitus). Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 20: 985–995.
Dube, M., CuIp, J., MacLatchy, D., Gillis, G., Parker, R., Courtenay, S. and Oilman, C. 2001. Utility of field-based artificial streams for assessing effects of pulp mill effluents on fish. J. Aquat. Ecosyst. Stress and Recov., 9: 85–102.
Dube, M. G., CuIp, J. M., Cash, K. J., Glozier, N. E., MacLatchy, D. L., Podemski, C. L. and Lowell, R. B. 2002. Artificial streams for environmental effects monitoring (EEM): development and application in Canada over the past decade. Wat. Qual. Res. J of Canada, 31: 155–180.
Dwemychuk, L. W. 1990. The receiving environment of the upper Fraser River: a pilot environmental effects monitoring program examining physical, chemical and biological elements of the system related to pulpmill effluents, West Vancouver, B.C.: Report Hatfield Consultants Ltd..
Environment Canada. 1998. Pulp and Paper Technical Guidance for Aquatic Environmental Effects Monitoring, Ottawa, ON, , Canada: Environment Canada, National EEM Office, Science Policy and Environmental Quality Branch. EEM/1998/1
Environment Canada. 2001. Metal Mining Guidance Document for Aquatic Environmental Effects Monitoring, Ottawa, ON, , Canada: Environment Canada, National EEM Office, Science Policy and Environmental Quality Branch. EEM/June 2002
Fairchild, J. E. and Little, E. E. 1993. Use of mesocosm studies to examine direct and indirect impacts of water quality on early life stages of fishes. Am. Fish. Soc. Sym., 14: 95–103.
Gelwick, F. P. and Matthews, W. J. 1993. “Artificial streams for studies of fish ecology.”. In Research in Artificial Streams: Applications, Uses and Abuses, Edited by: Lamberti, G. A. and Steinman, A. D. Vol. 12, 343–350. 313–384. J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc..
Gray, C. and Tuominen, T. 1998. Health of the Fraser River aquatic ecosystem, Vol. I, Ottawa, ON, , Canada: Environment Canada. EXDE FRAP 1998-11
Hall, T. J., Haley, R. K. and LaFleur, L. E. 1991. Effects of biologically treated bleached kraft mill effluent on cold water stream productivity in experimental stream channels. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 10: 1051–1060.
Lambeiti, G. A. and Steinman, A. D. 1993. Research in artificial streams: applications, uses, and abuses. J. N. Benthol. Soc., 12: 313–384.
Lowell, R. B., CuIp, J. M. and Wrona, F. J. 1995. Stimulation of increased short-term growth and development of mayflies by pulp mill effluent. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 14: 1529–1541.
Lowell, R. B., CuIp, J. M., Wrona, F. J. and Bothwell, M. L. 1996. “Effects of pulp mill effluent on benthic freshwater invertebrates: food availability and stimulation of increased growth and development.”. In Environmental Fate and Effects of Pulp and Paper Mill Effluents, Edited by: Servos, M. R., Munkittrick, K. R., Carey, J. H and Van Der Kraak, G. J. 525–532. Delray Beach, FL, , USA: St. Lucie Press.
Lowell, R. B., CuIp, J. M. and Dubé, M. G. 2000. A weight-of-evidence approach for northern river risk assessment: integrating the effects of multiple Stressors. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 19: 1182–1190.
McGreer, E. R. and Beizer, W. 1998. “Contaminant sources”. In Health of the Fraser River Aquatic Ecosystem, Edited by: Gray, C. and Tuominen, T. Vol. I, 7–22. Ottawa, ON, , Canada: Environment Canada. EXDE FRAP1998-11
Mohamed, M. N. 1997. “Phosphorus limitation of sestonic and sessile bacteria in the Fraser River and the effect of pulp mill effluent”. 121Saskatoon, Sask: Department of Biology, University of Saskatchewan. M. Sc. Thesis
Perrin, C. J., Wilkes, B. and Richardson, J. S. 1992. Stream periphyton and benthic insect responses to additions of treated acid mine drainage in a continuous-flow on-site mesocosm. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 11: 1513–1525.
Podemski, C. L. and CuIp, J. M. 1996. “Nutrient and contaminant effects of bleached kraft mill effluent on benthic algae and insects of the Athabasca River.”. In Environmental Fate and Effects of Pulp and Paper Mitt Effluents, Edited by: Servos, M. R., Munkittrick, K. R., Carey, J. H. and Van Der Kraak, G. J. 571–580. Delray Beach, FL, , USA: St. Lucie Press.
Shaw, J. L. and Kennedy, J. H. 1996. The use of aquatic field mesocosm studies in risk assessment. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 15: 605–607.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Manuscripts must be original. They must not be published or be under consideration for publication elsewhere, in whole or in part. It is required that the lead author of accepted papers complete and sign the MSU Press AEHM Author Publishing Agreement and provide it to the publisher upon acceptance.
