Systematic approach to weight of evidence in sediment quality assessment: Challenges and opportunities
Keywords:
benthic community structure, contaminated, ecoepidemiology, retrospectiveAbstract
Sediments are complex systems, and contaminants interact with them in a multitude of ways that influence exposure and effects on sediment-dwelling biota. Likewise a variety of non-chemical agents may act on benthic communities; these may dominate, contribute to or mask any effects from chemical contaminants. The first problem is to recognize that adverse effects have occurred. Once effects have been convincingly identified it is then necessary to assess likely causal agents retrospectively. Here we present a series of questions, elaborated from human health epidemiology, that can help to structure retrospective sediment assessments. We propose a method that aims to guide interpretation of various combinations of answers to the questions so that conclusions about the likelihood that identified agents have caused the observed effects in sediment systems can be consistently drawn. We demonstrate the approach by applying it to two published case studies. The first deals with estuarine communities in the northern Gulf of Mexico exposed to a wide variety of contaminants originating from a range of sources. The second involves a freshwater stream community impacted by road runoff. Although simpler than other weight of evidence approaches, we believe that the method provides a systematic, explicitly documented and consistent approach that may be particularly effective for defining priorities in situations where the evidence is limited and/or at least partly qualitative.
References
Balmford, A., Bruner, A., Cooper, P., Costanza, R., Farber, S., Green, R. E., Jenkins, M., Jefferiss, P., Jessamy, V., Madden, J., Munro, K., Myers, N., Naeem, S., Paavola, J., Rayment, M., Rosendo, S., Roughgarden, J., Trumper, K. and Turner, R. K. 2002. Economic reasons for conserving wild nature. Science, 297: 950–953. http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1073947http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12169718http://www4.infotrieve.com/newmedline/detail.asp?NameID=12169718&Session=&searchQuery=Science%5BJournal+Name%5D+AND+297%5BVolume%5D+AND+950%5BPage+Number%5D+AND+2002%5BPublication+Date%5D+AND+Balmford%5BAuthor+Name%5D&count=1
Buchman, M. F. 1999. NOAA Screening Quick Reference Tables, NOAA HAZMAT Report 99–1, Seattle, WA: Coastal Protection and Restoration Division, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
Burton, G. A. Jr., Batley, G. E., Chapman, P. M., Forbes, V. E., Smith, E. P., Reynoldson, T., Schlekat, C. E., den Besten, P. J., Bailer, A. J., Green, A. S. and Dwyer, R. L. 2002. A weight-of-evidence framework for assessing sediment (or other) contamination: Improving certainty in the decision-making process. Human Ecol. Risk Assess., 8: 1675–1696.
Calow, P. 1995. “Ecosystem health—a critical analysis of concepts”. In Evaluating and Monitoring the Health of Large-Scale Ecosystems, Edited by: Rapport, D. J., Gaudet, C. L. and Calow, P. pp. 33–41. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
Calow, P. 1996. “Ecology in ecotoxicology: some possible ‘rules of thumb’”. In ECOtoxicology: Ecological Dimensions, Edited by: Baird, D. J., Maltby, L., Greig-Smith, P. W. and Douben, P. E. T. pp. 5–12. London: Chapman & Hall.
Calow, P. 2001. ILSI Europe workshop on assessing and controlling industrial impacts on the aquatic environment with reference to food processing. Ecotoxico. Environm. Saf., 50: 89–101.
Calow, P. and Forbes, V. E. 2000. “Malacca Straits: Refined Risk Assessment”. In MP-EAS Technical Report No. 23/PEMSEA Technical Report Nr.1; GEF/UNDP/IMO Regional Programme for the Prevention and Management of Marine Pollution in the East Asian Seas Quezon City, Philippines
Chang, S., Steimle, F. W., Reid, R. N., Fromm, S. A., Zdanowicz, V. S. and Pikanowski, R. A. 1992. Association of benthic macrofauna with habitat types and quality in the New York Bight. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser., 89: 237–251.
Chapman, P. M. 1990. The Sediment Quality Triad approach to determining pollution-induced degradation. Sci. Tot. Environm., 97: 815–825.
Diaz, R. J. and Rosenberg, R. 1996. “The influence of sediment quality on functional aspects of marine benthic communities”. In Development and Progress in Sediment Quality Assessment: Rationale, Challenges, Techniques and Strategies, Edited by: Munawar, M. and Dave, G. pp. 57–68. Amsterdam: Ecovision World Monograph Series. Academic Publishing.
Duplisea, D. E. 1998. Structuring of benthic communities, with a focus on size spectra, Stockholm, , Sweden: Stockholm University. Ph.D. Thesis
Forbes, V. E. and Calow, P. 2002. Applying weight of evidence in retrospective ecological risk assessment when quantitative data are limited. Human Ecol. Risk Assess., 8: 1625–1640.
Giblin, A. E., Foreman, K. H. and Banta, G. T. 1995. “Biogeochemical processes and marine benthic community structure: Which follows which?”. In Linking Species and Ecosystems, Edited by: Jones, C. G. and Lawton, J. H. pp. 37–44. London: Chapman & Hall.
Gray, J. S. 1981. The Ecology of Marine Sediments: An Introduction to the Structure and Function of Marine Sediments, Cambridge: Cambridge Studies in Modern Biology 2. Cambridge University Press.
Hill, A. B. 1965. The environment and disease: Association or causation. Proc. Roy. Soc. Med., 58: 295–300. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=14283879http://www4.infotrieve.com/newmedline/detail.asp?NameID=14283879&Session=&searchQuery=Proc%2E+Roy%2E+Soc%2E+Med%2E%5BJournal+Name%5D+AND+58%5BVolume%5D+AND+295%5BPage+Number%5D+AND+1965%5BPublication+Date%5D+AND+Hill%5BAuthor+Name%5D&count=1
Long, E. R., Macdonald, D. D., Smith, S. L. and Calder, F. D. 1995. Incidence of adverse biological effects within ranges of chemical concentrations in marine and estuarine sediments. Environ. Manage., 19: 81–97.
Maltby, L., Forrow, D. M., Boxall, A. B. A., Calow, P. and Betton, C. I. 1995a. The effects of motorway runoff on freshwater ecosystems: 1. Field study. Environ. Tox. Chem., 14: 1079–1092.
Maltby, L., Boxall, A. B. A., Forrow, D. M., Calow, P. and Betton, C. I. 1995b. The effects of motorway runoff on freshwater ecosystems: 2. Identifying major toxicants. Environ. Tox. Chem., 14: 1093–1101.
Pearson, T. H. and Rosenberg, R. 1978. Macrobenthic succession in relation to organic enrichment and pollution of the marine environment. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol., Ann. Rev., 16: 229–311.
Rakocinski, C. F., Brown, S. S., Gaston, G. R., Heard, R. W., Walker, W. W. and Summers, J. K. 1997. Macrobenthic responses to natural and contaminant-related gradients in northern Gulf of Mexico estuaries. Ecol. Appl., 7: 1278–1298.
Rakocinski, C. F., Brown, S. S., Gaston, G. R., Heard, R. W. and Walker, W. W. 2000. Species-abundance-biomass responses by estuarine macrobenthos to sediment chemical contamination. J. Aquat. Ecosys. Stress Recov., 7: 201–214.
Sanders, H. L., Grassle, J. F., Hampson, G. R., Morse, L. S., Garner-Price, S. and Jones, C. C. 1980. Anatomy of an oil-spill: Long term effects of the grounding of the barge Florida off West Falmouth, Massachusetts. J. Mar. Res., 38: 265–380.
Smith, R. W., Bergen, M., Weisberg, S. B., Cadien, D., Dalkey, A., Montagne, D., Stull, J. K. and Velarde, R. G. 2001. Benthic response index for assessing infaunal communities on the southern California mainland shelf. Ecol. Appl., 11: 1073–1087.
Suter, G. W. II, Norton, S. B. and Cormier, S. M. 2002. A methodology for inferring the causes of observed impairments in aquatic ecosystems. Environ. Tox. Chem., 21: 1101–1111.
Tsutsumi, H. 1987. Population dynamics of Capitella capitata (Polychaeta: Capitellidae) in an organically polluted cove. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser., 36: 139–149.
Underwood, A. J. 1989. The analysis of stress in natural populations. Biol. J. Linn. Soc., 37: 51–78.
Underwood, A. J. 1997. Experiments in Ecology, Cambridge, , UK: Cambridge University Press.
Walsh, J. C., Sharpe, K. A., Breen, F. P. and Sonneman, A. J. 2001. Effects of urbanization on streams of the Melbourne region, Victoria, Australia. I. Benthic macroinvertebrate communities. Freshwat. Biol., 46: 535–551.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Manuscripts must be original. They must not be published or be under consideration for publication elsewhere, in whole or in part. It is required that the lead author of accepted papers complete and sign the MSU Press AEHM Author Publishing Agreement and provide it to the publisher upon acceptance.
