Restoring the chambo in Southern Malawi: Learning from the past or re-inventing the wheel?
Keywords:
restoration, existing knowledge, stakeholder involvementAbstract
Chambo is an important fish to Malawi's economy and to the livelihoods of local people in the southern end of Lake Malawi. Overexploitation of the chambo has been a source of concern since the 1930s. The biological and economic collapse of the fishery in Lake Malombe and the Upper Shire River in the early 1990s, and growing evidence in recent years of its decline in the Southeast Arm of Lake Malawi (the major productive area for the species) have galvanised the Government of Malawi into making an attempt to restore the chambo to former levels of production.
This paper argues that while the proposed solutions for restoring the chambo might be well intentioned, they nevertheless ignore existing knowledge and scholarship about fisheries management in African freshwater lakes gathered over the last six decades. A body of knowledge on the biological and scientific basis for regulating the chambo already exists. The missing link is an understanding and appreciation of the social, economic, political and institutional drivers on exploitation patterns of the chambo. Future management solutions must be based on the collective concerns of all potential users. More specifically, such solutions should be cognisant of local knowledge, fishers' experiences and the way they view and define their problems. If these are disregarded, finding solutions to the enormous challenge of restoring chambo stocks to their former status will be as difficult as grappling in the dark.
References
Agrawal, A. and Gibson, C. C. 1999. Enchantment and disenchantment: the role of community in natural resource conservation. World Development, 27: 626–649. [CSA]
Alimoso, S. B. 1984. Lilongwe: Fisheries Dept.. Annual Station Report for 1983 of 9/1/84. (Ref. No. D/14/Vol III/16)
Allison, E. H. 2002. Sustainable management of the African Great Lakes: Science for development?. Aquatic Ecosystem Health & Management, 5: 315–327. [INFOTRIEVE][CROSSREF][CSA]
Allison, E. H. and Ellis, F. 2001. The livelihoods approach and management of small-scale fisheries. Marine Policy, 25: 377–388. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Anderson, L. G. 1986. Enforcement issues in selecting fisheries management policy. Mar. Res. Econ., 6: 261–277. [CSA]
Baland, J. and Platteau, J.-M. 1996. Halting Degradation of natural Resources; Is there a Role for Rural Communities?, Oxford: FAO and Claredon Press.
Banda, M., Jamu, D., Njaya, F., Makuwila, M. and Maluwa, A., eds. The Chambo Restoration Strategic Plan. WorldFish Center Conference Proceedings 71. May 13–16 2003. Mangochi, Malawi: The WorldFish Center.
Bell, H. and Jamu, D. Assessing the potential for restocking, habitat enhancement, fish sanctuaries and aquaculture to restore the Chambo in Lake Malawi. WorldFish Center Conference Proceedings 71. May 13–16 2003. The Chambo Restoration Strategic Plan, Edited by: Banda, M., Jamu, D., Njaya, F., Makuwila, M. and Maluwa, A. pp.57–68. Mangochi, Malawi: The WorldFish Center.
Bell, R. and Donda, S. J. 1993. Community Participation Consultancy Report Vol. I. Fisheries Department Lilongwe, Malawi
Béné, C. 2004. Small scale fisheries: assessing their contribution to rural livelihoods in developing countries, Rome: FAO (multigr.).
Brummett, R. E. and Noble, R. 1995. Aquaculture for African smallerholders, Manila: ICLARM. Technical Reports No. 46,
Chirwa, W. C. The Lake Malombe and Upper Shire River fisheries co-management programme: An assessment. Proceedings from a regional workshop. March 18–20 1997, Mangochi, Malawi. Fisheries Co-management in Africa, Edited by: Normann, A. K., Raakjær Nielsen, J. and Sverdrup-Jensen, S. Denmark: IFM. 1998. Fisheries Co-management Research Report no 12
Chirwa, W. C. 1995. Fishing Rights, Ecology and Conservation Along Southern lake Malawi; 1920–1964. African Affairs, 95: 351–377. [CSA]
Coche, A. G., Haight, B. and Vinke, M. 1994. “Aquaculture development and research in sub-Saharan Africa”. In Synthesis of national reviews and indicative action plan research, Rome: FAO. CIFA Technical Paper No. 23
Cunningham, S. and Neiland, A. 2005. Investigating the linkages between fisheries, poverty and growth: Policy brief, London, UK: Department for International Development (DFID).
Dissi, C. S. 1984. Aggression Towards Fisheries Enforcement Officers, Lilongwe, Malawi: Fisheries Dept.. Station report of 24/4/84 (Ref. No. E/3/Vol. IV/5)
Donda, S. J. 2001. Theoretical Advancement and Institutional Analysis of Fisheries Co-management in Malawi: Experiences from Lake Malombe and Chiuta, PhD Thesis Denmark: University of Aarborg.
Donda, S. J. 1987. Zomba: Fisheries Dept. Lilongwe, Malawi National Archives. ‘Dangerous incidents during the 1986/87 closed season’ of 26/1/87 (Ref. No. e/3/160)
Donda, S. J. 1984. Zomba: Malawi National Archives. Station Report for August-December 1984 (Ref. No. D/14/Vol. III/27)
Ellis, F. and Kutengule, M. 2003. Livelihoods and Rural Poverty Reduction in Malawi. World Development, 31: 1495–1510. [CROSSREF][CSA]
FAO. 1996. Fisheries and Aquaculture in sub-Saharan Africa: Situation and Outlook in 1996, Rome: FAO. FAO Fisheries Circular No. 922
FAO. 1995. Review of the state of the World Fishery Resources: Aquaculture, Rome: FAO. FAO Fisheries Circular No. 886
FAO. 1993. Fisheries Management South-East Arm of Lake Malawi, Upper Shire River and Lake Malombe, Rome: FAO. CIFA Technical Paper 21. GOM/FAO/UNDP Chambo Fisheries Research Project
Ferguson, A. E., Derman, B. and Mkandawire, R. M. 1993. The New Development Rhetoric and Lake Malawi. Journal of the International African Institute, 3: 1–18. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Fisheries Department. 1993. Artisanal Fisheries Management Plan, Lilongwe, Malawi: Fisheries Department.
Flewwelling, O. 1994. An introduction to monitoring, control and surveillance systems for capture fisheries, Rome: FAO. FAO Technical paper 338
Garcia, S. M., Cochrane, K., van Santen, G. and Christy, F. 1999. Towards sustainable fisheries: a strategy for FAO and the World Bank. Ocean and Coastal Management, 42: 369–398. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Government of Malawi. 1997. Revised Fisheries Act, Zomba: Government of Malawi.
Government of Malawi/Overseas Development Administration (ODA). 1989. Artisanal Fisheries, Lilongwe: Fisheries Department. Assessment Project Report
Government of Malawi. 1973. Government of Malawi Laws, Malawi: Zomba. (Cap. 66:05)
Government of Nyasaland. 1949. Fisheries Ordinance No. 17: An Ordinance to provide for the Control and Protection of Fish and for the Regulation of Fisheries, Zomba: Government of Nyasaland.
Hara, M. M. 2005. “Participatory Fisheries Management in Lake Malombe and the Upper Shire River-Malawi”. In Confronting the Crisis in Community Conservation: Case Studies from Southern Africa, Edited by: Dzingirai, V. and Breen, C. 25–62. Peitermaritzburg: University of KwaZulu-Natal..
Hara, M. M. and Jul-Larsen, E. 2003. “The ‘Lords’ of Malombe; An Analysis of Fishery Development and Changes in Fishing Effort on Lake Malombe, Malawi”. In Management, Co-Management or No Management? Major Dilemmas in Southern African Freshwater Fisheries Edited by: Jul-Larsen, E., Kolding, J., Overa, R., Raakjaer Nielsen, J. and van Zwieten, P. A. M. 179–200. Rome FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 462/2
Hara, M. and Nielsen, J. R. 2003. “Experiences with fisheries co-management in Africa”. In The Fisheries Co-Management Experience: Accomplishments, Challenges and Prospects, Edited by: Wilson, D. C., Raakjaer Nielsen, J. and Degnbol, P. 81–95. Dordrecht, , The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Hara, M. M., Donda, S. J. and Njaya, F. J. 2002. “Lessons from Malawi's experience with fisheries co-management initiatives”. In Africa's Inland Fisheries: The Management Challenge, Edited by: Geheb, K. and Sarch, M.-T. 31–48. Kampala: Foutain Publishers.
Hara, M. M. 2001a. Could Co-management provide a solution to the problem of artisanal fisheries management on the Southeast Arm of Lake Malawi?, Ph.D. Thesis Cape Town: University of the Western Cape.
Hara, M. M. 2001b. Could marine resources provide a short-term solution to declining fish supply in SADC inland countries? The case of horse mackerel. Food Policy, 26: 11–34. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Hatcher, A., Jaffry, S., Thiebaud, O. and Bennet, E. 2000. Normative and social influences affecting compliance with fisheries regulations. Land Economics, 76: 448–61. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Hviding, E. and Jul-Larsen, E. 1995. Community Resource Management in Tropical Fisheries, , 1st edition, Windhoek: University of Namibia.
Jentoft, S. 1989. Fisheries co-management: Delegating government responsibility to fishermen's organisations. Marine Policy, 13: 137–154. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Jul-Larsen, E., Kolding, J., Overa, R., Raakjaer Nielsen, J. and van Zwieten, P. A. M., eds. 2003. Management, co-management or no management? Major dilemmas in southern African freshwater fisheries, Rome: FAO. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 462/1
Jul-Larsen, E. and Semu, L. 1997. Social impact assessment of interventions in the Shire Management Project, Bergen: CMI. (mimeo)
Jumpha, D. J. 1988. Zomba: Fisheries Dept. Lilongwe, and Malawi National Archives. Annual Enforcement report for 1988 of 19/5/89. (Ref. No. E/3/Vol. VIII/202) and Licensing report for Nov. 1988 (Ref. No. e/3/59 of 14/12/88)
Kapeleta, M. 1973. The coming of the Tonga and the commercialisation of fishing in Monkey Bay area: a case study, Zomba: Chancellor College, Univeristy of Malawi. Sociology Seminar Paper
Lowe, R. H. 1952. Report on the Tilapia and other Fish and Fisheries of Lake Nyasa 1945–47, London: Colonial Office. Colonial Office Fishery Publications Vol. No. 2
Mandala, E. C. 1990. Work and control in a peasant economy: A history of the Lower Tchiri Valley in Malawi, 1859–1960, Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
Martinez-Espinosa, M. 1996. Rome: FAO. Report of the expert consultation on small-scale rural aquaculture (Rome, Italy, 28–31 May 1996). FAO Fisheries Report No. 548,
McCraken, J. 1987. Fishing and the Colonial Economy. Journal of African History, 28: 413–429. [CSA]
Mijere, L. K. 1977. Zomba: Fisheries Dept. Lilongwe. Malawi National Archives. Report of M. Mwachumu's case held at 2nd magistrate court. (Ref. No. e/3/14/6/77)
Ng'ombe, E. L. 1981. Zomba: Fisheries Dept. Lilongwe. Malawi National Archives. Close Season report for 1980/81 of 13/4/81 (Ref. No. D/14/vol. VI/12)
Ostrom, E. 1990. Governing the commons: evolution of institutions for collective active, Cambridge, , England: Cambridge University Press.
Parsons, L. S. 1995. Management of marine fisheries in Canada. Can. Bul. Fish. Aquat. Sci., : 225 [CSA]
Pollnac, R. B. 1991. “Social and cultural characteristics in small-scale fishery development”. In Putting people first. Sociological variables in rural development, Edited by: Cernea, M. M. 259–300. New York: Oxford University Press.
Raakjær Nielsen, J., Degnbol, P., Viswanathan, K. K., Ahmed, M., Hara, M. M. and Abdullah, N. M. R. 2004. Fisheries Co-Management—An Institutional Innovation? Lessons from South East Asia and Southern Africa. Marine Policy, 28: 151–160. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Raakjær Nielsen, J. 2003. An analytical framework for studying: compliance and legitimacy in fisheries management. Marine Policy, 27: 425–432. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Rogers, K. and Biggs, H. 1999. Integrating Indicators, endpoints and value systems in strategic management of the Kruger National Park. Freshwater Biology, 41: 439–451. [CROSSREF][CSA]
Ruddle, K., Hviding, E. and Johannes, R. E. 1992. Marine resources management in the context of customary tenure. Marine Resource Economics, 7: 249–273. [CSA]
Sarch, M.-T. and Allison, E. H. Fluctuating fisheries in Africa's inland waters: Well-adapted livelihoods, maladapted management. Microbehavior and Macroresults: Proceedings of the Tenth Biennial Conference of the International Institute of Fisheries Economics and Trade Presentations. July 10–14 2000. Oregon: Oregon State University Press. http://osu.orst.edu/dept/IIFET
Singleton, S. and Taylor, M. 1992. Common Property, Collective Action and Community. Journal of Theoretical Politics, 4: 309–324. [CSA]
Sutinen, J. G., Rieser, A. and Gauvin, J. R. 1990. Measuring and explaining non-compliance in federally managed fisheries. Ocean Development and International Law, 21: 335–372. [CSA]
Sverdrup-Jensen, S. and Raakjaer Nielsen, J. Fisheries Co-management in Africa. Proceedings from a regional workshop on fisheries co-management research. March 18–20 1997. Denmark: IFM. Fisheries Co-management Research Report no 12
Trewavas, E. 1983. Tilapiine fishes of the genera Sarotherodon, Oreochromis and Danakilia, London: British Museum (Natural History).
Trewavas, E. 1942. Nyasa fishes of the genus Tilapia and a new species from Portuguese East Africa. Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist., 11: 294–306. [CSA]
Turner, G. F. and Robinson, R. L. 1990. Ecology, morphology and taxonomy of the Lake Malawi Oreochromis (Nyasalapia) species flock. Ann. Mus. Roy. Afr. Centr. Sc. Zool., 262: 23–28. [CSA]
Williamson, R. B. 1966. Analysis of Ring-net Catch Data from the Southeast Arm of Lake Malawi, 1946–1966, Malawi: Malawi Fisheries Department.
Young, O. R. 1979. Compliance and Public Authority, Baltimore: John Hopkins Univ. Press.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Manuscripts must be original. They must not be published or be under consideration for publication elsewhere, in whole or in part. It is required that the lead author of accepted papers complete and sign the MSU Press AEHM Author Publishing Agreement and provide it to the publisher upon acceptance.
