Modelling phosphorus dynamics in Cootes Paradise marsh: Uncertainty assessment and implications for eutrophication management
Keywords:
phosphorus modelling, nutrient recycling, sediment dynamics, Areas of ConcernAbstract
Cootes Paradise marsh, a hypereutrophic wetland draining into the western end of Hamilton Harbour, Ontario, has historically been considered an important regulatory factor of the severity of local eutrophication phenomena. In this study, we present a modelling exercise that aims to draw inference on the relative contribution of various external and internal flux rates to the phosphorus budget of Cootes Paradise. We first examined the capacity of a phosphorus mass-balance model, accounting for the interplay among water column, sediments and macrophytes, to reproduce the observed total phosphorus dynamics over a 17-year period (1996–2012). Water level fluctuations were one of the key challenges for balancing the phosphorus budget during model calibration. Our analysis shows that the model satisfactorily reproduced the average seasonal patterns, as well as the year-to-year total phosphorus variability (coefficient of determination = 0.20, relative error = 26.8%, root mean square error = 62.2 μg P l−1, model efficiency = 0.15). However, our model failed to capture two years of the study period (1997 and 2007), when ambient TP levels significantly deviated from the typically prevailing conditions. Model sensitivity analysis identified the sedimentation of particulate material and diffusive reflux from sediments as two critical processes to characterize the phosphorus cycle in the wetland. Based on the current parameter specification, our model postulates that the sediments still act as a net sink, whereas macrophyte processes (respiration rates, nutrient uptake from interstitial water) appear to play a minor role. We conclude by discussing the various sources of uncertainty and additional remedial actions required in Cootes Paradise marsh to realize a shift from the current turbid-phytoplankton dominated state to its former clear-macrophyte dominated state.
References
Arhonditsis, G.B., Brett, M.T., 2004. Evaluation of the current state of mechanistic aquatic biogeochemical modeling. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 271, 13–26.
Asaeda, T., Trung, V.K., Manatunge, J., 2000. Modeling the effects of macrophyte growth and decomposition on the nutrient budget in Shallow Lakes. Aquat. Bot. 68(3), 217–237.
Charlton, M.N., 2001. The Hamilton Harbour Remedial Action Plan: Eutrophication. Verhandlung Internationale Vereinigung Limnologie 27, 4069–4072.
Chow-Fraser, P., 2005. Ecosystem response to changes in water level of Lake Ontario marshes: lessons from the restoration of Cootes Paradise marsh. Hydrobiologia 539(1), 189–204.
Chow-Fraser, P., Lougheed, V., Le Thiec, V., Crosbie, B., Simser, L., Lord, J., 1998. Long-term response of the biotic community to fluctuating water levels and changes in water quality in Cootes Paradise marsh, a degraded coastal wetland of Lake Ontario. Wetlands Ecol. Manage. 6(1), 19–42.
Croft, M.V., Chow-Fraser, P., 2007. Use and development of the wetland macrophyte index to detect water quality impairment in fish habitat of Great Lakes coastal marshes. J. Great Lakes Res. 33(Supplement 3), 172–197.
Eadie, B.J., Schwab, D.J., Johengen, T.H., Lavrentyev, P.J., Miller, G.S., Holland, R.E., Leshkevich, G.A., Lansing, M.B., Morehead, N.R., Robbins, J.A., 2002. Particle transport, nutrient cycling, and algal community structure associated with a major winter-spring sediment resuspension event in southern Lake Michigan. J. Great Lakes Res. 28(3), 324–337.
Granéli, W., Solander, D., 1988. Influence of aquatic macrophytes on phosphorus cycling in lakes. Hydrobiologia 170(1), 245–266.
Gudimov, A., Ramin, M., Labencki, T., Wellen, C., Shelar, M., Shimoda, Y., Boyd, D., Arhonditsis, G.B., 2011. Predicting the response of Hamilton Harbour to the nutrient loading reductions: A modeling analysis of the “ecological unknowns”. J. Great Lakes Res. 37(3), 494–506.
Gudimov, A., Stremilov, S., Ramin, M., Arhonditsis, G.B., 2010. Eutrophication risk assessment in Hamilton Harbour: System analysis and evaluation of nutrient loading scenarios. J. Great Lakes Res. 36(3), 520–539.
Hall, J.D., O'Connor, K., Ranieri, J., 2006. Progress toward delisting a Great Lakes Area of Concern: The role of integrated research and monitoring in the Hamilton Harbour Remedial Action Plan. Environ. Monit. Assess. 113(1–3), 227–243.
Harwell, M.C., Havens, K.E., 2003. Experimental studies on the recovery potential of submerged aquatic vegetation after flooding and desiccation in a large subtropical lake. Aquat. Bot. 77(2), 135–151.
Hiriart-Baer, V.P., Milne, J., Charlton, M.N., 2009. Water quality trends in Hamilton Harbour: Two decades of change in nutrients and chlorophyll a
. J. Great Lakes Res. 35(2), 293–301.
Howard-Williams, C., Allanson, B.R., 1981. Phosphorus cycling in a dense Potamogeton pectinatus L. Bed. Oecologia 49(1), 56–66.
Johengen, T.H., Biddanda, B.A., Cotner, J.B., 2008. Stimulation of Lake Michigan plankton metabolism by sediment resuspension and river runoff. J. Great Lakes Res. 34(2), 213–227.
Kelton, N., Chow-Fraser, P., 2005. A simplified assessment of factors controlling phosphorus loading from oxygenated sediments in a very shallow eutrophic lake. Lake Reserv. Manage. 21(3), 223–230.
Kim, D.-K., Zhang, W., Rao, Y., Watson, S., Mugalingam, S., Labencki, T., Dittrich, M., Morley, A., Arhonditsis, G.B., 2013. Improving the representation of internal nutrient recycling with phosphorus mass balance models: A case study in the Bay of Quinte, Ontario, Canada. Ecol. Model. 256, 53–68.
Lougheed, V.L., Crosbie, B., Chow-Fraser, P., 1998. Predictions on the effect of common carp (Cyprinus carpio) exclusion on water quality, zooplankton, and submergent macrophytes in a Great Lakes wetland. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 55(5), 1189–1197.
Lougheed, V.L., Theÿsmeÿer, T., Smith, T., Chow-Fraser, P., 2004. Carp exclusion, food-web interactions, and the restoration of Cootes Paradise marsh. J. Great Lakes Res. 30(1), 44–57.
Mayer, T., Rosa, F., Charlton, M., 2005. Effect of sediment geochemistry on the nutrient release rates in Cootes Paradise marsh, Ontario, Canada. Aquat. Ecosyst. Health Mgmt. 8(2), 133–145.
Minns, C.K., 1986. A simple whole-lake phosphorus model and a trial application to the Bay of Quinte. In: C.K. Minns,
D.A. Hurley,
K.H. Nicholls (Eds.),
Project Quinte: Point-Source Phosphorus Control and Ecosystem Response in the Bay of Quinte, Lake Ontario
, pp. 84–90. Canadian Special Publication of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
Minns, C.K., Moore, J.E., Seifried, K.E., 2004. Nutrient loads and budgets in the Bay of Quinte, Lake Ontario, 1972 to 2001. Great Lakes Laboratory for Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, Bayfield Institute, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Burlington, Ontario.
Moore, R.B., Johnson, C.M., Robinson, K.W., Deacon, J.R., 2004. Estimation of total nitrogen and phosphorus in New England streams using spatially referenced regression models. US Department of the Interior, US Geological Survey, New Hampshire.
Prescott, K.L., Tsanis, I.K., 1997. Mass balance modelling and wetland restoration. Ecol. Eng. 9(1–2), 1–18.
Ramin, M., Perhar, G., Shimoda, Y., Arhonditsis, G.B., 2012. Examination of the effects of nutrient regeneration mechanisms on plankton dynamics using aquatic biogeochemical modeling. Ecol. Model. 240, 139–155.
Ramin, M., Stremilov, S., Labencki, T., Gudimov, A., Boyd, D., Arhonditsis, G.B., 2011. Integration of numerical modeling and Bayesian analysis for setting water quality criteria in Hamilton Harbour, Ontario, Canada. Environ. Modell. Softw. 26(4), 337–353.
Schallenberg, M., Burns, C.W., 2004. Effects of sediment resuspension on phytoplankton production: teasing apart the influences of light, nutrients and algal entrainment. Freshwat. Biol. 49(2), 143–159.
Scheffer, M., Straile, D., van Nes, E.H., Hosper, H., 2001. Climatic warming causes regime shifts in lake food webs. Limnol. Oceanogr. 46(7), 1780–1783.
Schelske, C.L., Carrick, H.J., Aldridge, F.J., 1995. Can wind-induced resuspension of meroplankton affect phytoplankton dynamics? J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc. 14(4), 616–630.
Schriver, P.E.R., Bogestrand, J., Jeppesen, E., Søndergaard, M., 1995. Impact of submerged macrophytes on fish-zooplankton-phytoplankton interactions: large-scale enclosure experiments in a shallow eutrophic lake. Freshwat. Biol. 33(2), 255–270.
Skafel, M.G., 2000. Exchange flow between Hamilton Harbour and Cootes Paradise. J. Great Lakes Res. 26(1), 120–125.
Soldat, D.J., Petrovic, A.M., 2008. The fate and transport of phosphorus in turfgrass ecosystems. Crop Science 48(6), 2051–2065.
Soldat, D., Petrovic, A.M., Ketterings, Q., 2009. Effect of soil phosphorus levels on phosphorus runoff concentrations from turfgrass. Water Air Soil Pollut. 199(1–4), 33–44.
Søndergaard, M., Jeppesen, E., Kristensen, P., Sortkjaer, O., 1990. Interactions between sediment and water in a shallow and hypertrophic lake: a study on phytoplankton collapses in Lake Søbygård, Denmark. Hydrobiologia 191(1), 139–148.
Suding, K.N., Gross, K.L., Houseman, G.R., 2004. Alternative states and positive feedbacks in restoration ecology. Trends Ecol. Evol. 19(1), 46–53.
Theÿsmeÿer, T., 2011. Project Paradise Planning to 2015: RBG contribution to the HHRAP for the restoration of the wetlands. Natural Lands Deparment, Royal Botanical Gardens (RBG), Burlington, ON, Canada.
Theÿsmeÿer, T., Galbraith, D., 2007.
Biedermann Packaging Fire: Effects on Cootes Paradise marsh
. Royal Botanical Gardens, Burlington, ON, Canada.
Theÿsmeÿer, T., Reich, B., Bowman, J.E., 2009.
Water Quality Characterization of the Main Tributaries of the Garden's Property - Spencer Creek, Chedoke Creek, Borer's Creek and Grindstone Creek
. Royal Botanical Gardens, Burlington, ON, Canada.
Thomasen, S., Chow-Fraser, P., 2012. Detecting changes in ecosystem quality following long-term restoration efforts in Cootes Paradise marsh. Ecol. Indicators 13(1), 82–92.
Twilley, R.R., Lugo, A.E., Patterson-Zucca, C., 1986. Litter production and turnover in basin mangrove forests in southwest Florida. Ecology 67(3), 670–683.
Wellen, C., Arhonditsis, G.B., Labencki, T., Boyd, D., 2014a. Application of the SPARROW model in watersheds with limited information: a Bayesian assessment of the model uncertainty and the value of additional monitoring. Hydrol. Process. 28, 1260–1283.
Wellen, C., Arhonditsis, G.B., Long, T., Boyd, D., 2014b. Quantifying the uncertainty of nonpoint source attribution in distributed water quality models: A Bayesian assessment of SWAT's sediment export predictions. J. Hydrol. 519, Part D, 3353–3368.
Whillans, T.H., 1996. Historic and comparative perspectives on rehabilitation of marshes as habitat for fish in the lower Great Lakes basin. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 53(S1), 58–66.
Wilcox, D.A., Whillans, T.H., 1999. Techniques for restoration of disturbed coastal wetlands of the Great Lakes. Wetlands 19(4), 835–857.
Winter, J.G., Duthie, H.C., 2000. Export coefficient modeling to assess phosphorus loading in an urban watershed. JAWRA 36(5), 1053–1061.
Wium-Andersen, S., Anthoni, U., Christophersen, C., Houen, G., 1982. Allelopathic effects on phytoplankton by substances isolated from aquatic macrophytes (Charales). OIKOS 39(2), 187–190.
Zhang, J., Jørgensen, S.E., Beklioglu, M., Ince, O., 2003. Hysteresis in vegetation shift - Lake Mogan prognoses. Ecol. Model. 164(2–3), 227–238.
Published
Issue
Section
License
Manuscripts must be original. They must not be published or be under consideration for publication elsewhere, in whole or in part. It is required that the lead author of accepted papers complete and sign the MSU Press AEHM Author Publishing Agreement and provide it to the publisher upon acceptance.
